If you have spent any time on either side of the hiring table in New Zealand, you know the drill.
For a hiring manager, it looks like an unsolicited email landing in your inbox on a Tuesday morning: "Hi there, I’ve just met a superstar candidate in your sector-details attached." Attached is an unvetted CV, sometimes with the candidate’s name and contact details still sitting right at the top, followed by standard fee terms in the fine print.
For a candidate, it feels far worse. It’s the sinking realisation that your profile, the career history you shared in confidence, is being blasted around town to firms you never agreed to speak with, purely so an agency can "stake a claim" on you in case you eventually get hired there.
In the recruitment industry, this is known as CV farming or blanket pitching. It is one of the most predatory, transactional shortcuts in the business, and it is far from the Ethical Recruitment we built as the second pillar of our business.
Throwing a speculative blanket over the market is built on a volume game: send enough profiles to enough inboxes, attach a fee schedule, and hope something sticks. Worse still, some agencies will send a profile without ever having a proper conversation with the candidate or the client, only to turn around months later and try to claim a fee when that person lands a role through a recruiter who actually did the matchmaking work. On the surface, blanket pitching looks like proactive hustle. In reality, it damages everyone involved.
For candidates, it puts privacy and reputation on the line.
In a close-knit professional market like New Zealand, discretion is everything. Sending out profiles with identifying details-or pitching a candidate to firms without their consent-doesn't just breach privacy. It risks exposing a confidential job search to current employers and peers before a genuine opportunity even exists. It also damages your reputation in the market, it’s hard to show you’re being deliberate about where your next career move is when some desk jockey has sent your CV to every business in your industry.
For employers, it wastes time and creates friction.
When an agency fires off profiles without asking what the role actually entails, where the progression sits, or how someone fits long-term, they aren't solving your hiring problem. You end up sifting through unvetted CVs from recruiters who are chasing a quick transaction rather than understanding your team.
As we have said since day one: "You can sell your reputation once, but you'll never buy it back".
At Blackthorn Talent Acquisition, our second pillar is simple: discretion and honesty come before fees.
There is a massive difference between strategically sharing an anonymised snapshot of talent to open a genuine conversation with a client, and mass-mailing CVs to stake a fee claim. True ethical recruitment is about doing the matchmaking work properly:
Asking the right questions first: Before we ever put a professional forward, we dig into what the role actually requires, where the career progression leads, and how that person will fit the business long-term.
Protecting candidate confidentiality: A candidate’s name and contact details are never shared without explicit consent. Real trust means having proper, in-depth conversations so candidates know exactly where they are being represented and why.
Earning the fee through real work: We don't play "finders keepers" with people's careers. We believe a placement only counts when we have done the legwork-vetting thoroughly, aligning expectations on both sides and ensuring that the client, the candidate, and Blackthorn all genuinely win.
Ethical recruitment isn't about taking the moral high ground; it is about doing the job properly. When candidates know their privacy is respected and their career goals are genuinely understood, the best talent in the market is willing to talk. And when clients know we value real matchmaking over a quick fee, they get hires who actually belong.
In our first pillar, Sustainable Recruitment (The Quick Fix), we looked at why recruiting for year two always outlasts panic hiring for next week. Ethical Recruitment is the trust and integrity that holds those long-term partnerships together.
Next in our series, we will look at our third pillar: What is Resilient Recruitment? - and how steady, grounded counsel helps businesses and professionals navigate shifting markets and tight talent conditions with confidence.
Want to have a confidential conversation about your next career move, or looking for a search partner who treats your brand's reputation like their own?
Get in touch with the Blackthorn team today.